« John from Cincinnati | Main | Visual Digg-ing » Forget Jakob, blog from your heart and soulJakob Neilsen says one should write articles, not blog postings, not far from a conclusion I was, ahem, blogging a few days ago. Like so much of his writing, this latest from Nielsen has some useful info, makes some good points, but (like most pronouncements from consultants) comes across as inauthentic. I think Michael Heilemann has his number: The problem with Jakob Nielsen–or perhaps rather his audience as it were–is that his articles, top 10’s and ‘usability tests’ are outdated, largely irrelevant and when applicable, made up of nothing but easily thought up logical conclusions aimed at the dull gray ‘we want to be hip with the youngsters, yo’ corporate market, from which he makes his money. As a blog strategist, I would never tell my clients to write a particular length or depth. The first rule is to be authentic, write what you know, write from the heart. jon posted this at 5:26 PM |
read weblogsky! latest posts: |







Comments
Amen, and nuts to Jakob. Kathy Sierra ran a *great* blog with occasional essays. (Come back, Kathy!) Glenn Reynolds has done fairly well for himself with a high proportion of micro-posts.
Jakob's advice is like telling a basketball player to specialize only on long-range shots. That's fine if that's your stock in trade, or if you want to play guard in the pros. But if you're 7'2" and 320# . . . focus on layups, baby hooks, and dunks.
Another way of saying "be authentic" is to say do what works for *you*. True in sports, true for book writers, true for attorneys, true . . . well, it's just TRUE. So why wouldn't it be for blogging, too?
Posted by: Tim Walker | July 21, 2007 7:57 PM